SEVEN OVERLOOKED INDEPENDENT FILMS OF 2011

By in News
on Monday, January 2nd, 2012

The world doesn’t need another list of the best films of the year, but after considering my own recent lists, I realized there were a handful of movies‹excellent independent work that has largely flown under the radar‹that even I initially overlooked. Here are seven bold American
low-budget movies from 2011 that may have been forgotten in theatrical release, but should make for essential home viewing (if you haven’t seen them yet) in 2012. And I’ll be among the first in line to see where these young directors go next.

1. Silver Bullets. ­ All I can say is that I hope Joe Swanberg doesn’t burn himself out. Fourteen movies in six years is enough to kill most directors, but Swanberg not only perseveres, but he’s far smarter and skilled than most critics give him credit for, and with Silver Bullets, I think he’s proven them wrong. The movie that inspired this list, Swanberg got short shrift from the N.Y. Times, but the film deserves a second look: A sharp looking, harshly critical (self-referential) portrait of the insecurities of male directors and their female actresses, Swanberg seems to be working with the likes of Atom Egoyan and Jean-Luc Godard in mind. Don’t scoff at the comparisons. At 30-years-old, he could very well get there. The last shot may be pretentious, but it’s a beautiful and haunting wonder.

2. The Future. ­While many critics didn’t buy Miranda July’s Me and You and Everyone We Know, and others bandied about the twee word to describe The Future, July’s latest delivers equal doses of charm and profundity, oddness and transcendence. I contend that one mysterious, enigmatic scene, in which July dances inside a big T-shirt, is one of the most enthralling movie moments of the year.

3. Putty Hill. ­ Matthew Porterfield’s contemplative, exquisitely lensed snapshot of working-class white America on the fringes of Baltimore has been hailed among certain indie circles, but it’s worth another shout-out. Innovatively mixing fiction and documentary techniques, the film offers an emotionally truthful portrait of its down-and-out characters with empathy and sensitivity.

4. Cold Weather. Mixing twentysomething aimlessness, humorous nods to detective fiction and long, contemplative takes of his Portland milieu, Aaron Katz proves he’s moved beyond the mere “mumblecore” label to create a work of emotional maturity and touching subtlety.

5. Terri. What could have been just another tale of high school outsiders becomes something subdued, lyrical and even transcendent. Azazal Jacobs makes the familiar new again.

6. Circumstance. An assured drama about two young women grappling with sexuality and repression in Iran, Maryam Keshavarz handles her riskily melodramatic material with a remarkable amount of restraint and tenderness. And it’s all got political balls: I don’t think I ever believed I’d see a movie where someone screams in Farsi, “Fuck the Mullahs.”

7. Bellflower. Evan Glodell is more than just a cinematic tinkerer. I’m not the first to mention his no-budget debut in a list like this, but what I like about it differs from most: Sure, the flamethrowers and muscle cars are kind of cool, but the love-story-gone-horribly-wrong is a little too naïve for me. What sets it apart is a sense of space and burning energy. While I hear Glodell might do a horror film, I’d like to see him ditch the violence and make a road movie for adults.

You can follow any follow up comments to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.

  • http://twitter.com/adamjeal Adam Jeal

    The Future was criminally overlooked. There’s for more to Miranda July than anyone ever gives her credit for just lazy, tired, and desperately UN-imaginative comments (the complete antithesis of her and her work).

    • Habu

      July is the opitome of narcissistic/Silverlake hipster mumble core. Art doesn’t exist in a vacuum, but some people think it does, and they named that vacuum Silverlake.

      • http://twitter.com/adamjeal Adam Jeal

        bollocks!

        • Habu

          Why exactly should I banish those ‘phrases’? They are legitimate to contemporary cinema.

          P.S. Before you nitpick typos, you should learn the definitions of the big fancy words you’re using. ‘Mumble core’ and ‘hipster’ are actually ‘terms’, not ‘phrases’, Mr. Lexicon.

          • http://twitter.com/adamjeal Adam Jeal

            My point was that most supposed criticism re MJ seems to revolve around and accuse her of being part of a group of facile posers. I think she has a genuine point of view and doesn’t deserve to be lumped in with this glibly defined cultural fad. Her work has vigour (not just the films) and she has been working for many years. Most ‘critics’, including yourself just fall back on lazy phrases that form part of the zeitgiest or cultural lexicon and offer no genuine insight, just snide disdain & apathy. Stop repeating the same, tired old shit (like the others) and say WHY the WORK doesn’t effect you.

          • http://twitter.com/ekimnamwen mike n

            of course miranda july doesn’t belong in the same group with all the mumblecore hacks. her work is infinitely more interesting and genuine. whoever lumps her in that group is ignorant.

          • Anonymous

            Adam, Ms. July seems like she doesn’t care about what the audience thinks as long as she gets her avant-garde point across.  Her cat voice was annoying too.  I think she likes to piss off the audience.  Don’t get me wrong, I like Miranda July.  I think she is a creative genius but I just don’t think cinema is her best medium. 

          • Habu

            Agreed.

          • Habu

            Clearly her work inspires you – to the point of defending it so passionately. It doesn’t resonate with me. And apparently I’m far from being alone. I just prefer deeper narrative complexity beyond self-indulgent artwork. I’m not saying she’s isn’t an artist – I think she is. But craft and skill must also be considered in the medium of motion picture storytelling. Otherwise every piece of crap will be considered art – hence the growing intolerance for mumblecore.

          • http://twitter.com/adamjeal Adam Jeal

            You still cannot explain why in your opinion, the work is badly crafted. Even Film_Shark is more forthcoming by believing her M.O. to be to piss off her audience. Although I disagree, at least that is going somewhere. You hate her cause you believe her to be typical of a manufactured ‘scene’ that you despise. Nothing more, nothing less.

      • Dan Delago

        Good one Habu.  LOL

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Dylan-Bradford/100002643588743 Dylan Bradford

    The Sundance Film Festival’s 6 head programmers have acknowledged that they do not in fact watch the over 10,000 film submissions, and that they hire “someone” else, ( 30 to 40) other people to screen them before they are passed along ( in their own words) so why don’t they divulge the information as to the qualifications of these people? Why would any serious filmmaker feel comfortable about the fairness and spend 65.00 or 75.00 to simply let anyone look at their film? Would you “pay someone from craigslist” for instance and say, I will give you money to let you look at my film and tell me what you think.
    This is about as ludicrous as stupidity can get, but Sundance operates as do other film festivals off of desperation, and John Cooper doesn’t care about watching these films, he is out and about traveling the globe looking at films from other festivals, he does NOT watch the films.
    Sundance films are not independent, its who you know, not what you know or what you have made, they could care less and there is proof of that being made into a film that reveals the corporate corruption including interviews with those who worked at Sundance and behind the scenes. The movie is called “Scam Fest” and this film will open filmmakers eyes to what really happens to their films, and money. John Cooper, Shari Frilot, Jill Miller, Keri Putnam and all the rest of them are sold out and corrupt people, they have no talent, never made a film, have no qualifications other then to sit in a chair and push around paper and distribute money, and all the while Robert Redford does nothing, he simply states his usual rhetoric, “We support filmmakers” he is like a wind up doll.
    Well known film reps bring in 4 to 10 films and have private screenings and pay nothing, while your film sits in a box waiting to be watched by some college nit wits busy on their text phones forwarding through submissions, that wouldn’t have the time, patience or intelligence to know what a really great film is, and know what? Who gets duped in the end? You the people, the arts, movie goers, and so we have the same old cliches only boxed up “independently” and the real gems go to the garbage. The only people that have the nerve, and the integrity to stand up to Cooper and all his cohorts in their money making scams is the Yeager’s whose film Jesus of Malibu was never given the chance, the film trailer, e-mails, and info all reveal specifically how corrupt Sundance is and has been for over 25 years. It is only a matter of time when the states attorney shuts them down from ripping the general public off of millions of dollars each year, millions do the math, and has every filmmaker agree to their terms which is a contractual agreement, if this were any other institution, these people would be behind bars in prison, but the same old show goes on and on, smoke and mirrors, and the on-line publications encourage it, and they don’t write about it either, Filmmaker Magazine, Film Threat, Indie Wire, all of them don’t want you to know either because they are all making money in this, if not why don’t they tell you some really important information like Sundance is corrupt? Why don’t they get down to the question and interview; “Dear programmers tell us, who watch’s the 10,000 films and can we speak with these “people” please?  That won’t happen, and so in the meantime I not only tip my hat to the dear filmmakers William and Anais Yeager who have in my mind made the greatest film the world my ever have had a chance to see, but has brought all this to our attention, and it is quite obvious when you look at the film trailers for Jesus of Malibu, that this could be the most creative and solely true independent film ever made, way ahead of it’s time, and when you consider that Sundance had no interest in simply answering the Yeager’s e-mail or phone call regarding their film trilogy, it is obvious that it is about who you know, and Kevin Smith will always get in line before you or I ever do.
    Lets call this what it is for once and for all, its a big party, its about money, not about art, and it is about ripping people off, real indy filmmakers who keep submitting for years and years what a sad thing this has become, and shame to all those who don’t tell you about it, shame on them and you filmmakers who keep feeding this “beast”.

  • http://twitter.com/ekimnamwen mike n

    I don’t know what drugs you are taking, but you really need to stop taking them. Joe Swanberg is by far one of the worst filmmakers of my generation. Seriously. There’s no competition. His work is total shit. I wish I could come up with a more comprehensive description, but I can’t. His work is no better than a giant turd floating in the toilet. The fact that you put him #1 on your list, above filmmakers with actual talent makes this list totally moot.

    There’s a reason his movies clear out the theaters and its not b/c he’s a genius that people don’t understand. In fact it’s the exact opposite. I hope you are wrong. I really hope Joe Swanberg burns himself out. It
    would be a great thing for the Indie Film world and the audience if there never was a Joe
    Swanberg movie ever made again. The world doesn’t need any more mindless, self-indulgent, smug movies made for hipsters.

    • NotMikeN

      You’re just jealous…make a film better than Silver Bullets and post a link to the trailer

      • Habu

        You don’t have to be a filmmaker to be entitled to have an opinion. I mean, isn’t that the right audiences inherently have since a film is for them? Unless the film is self-indulgent, narcissistic mumble core, that is…

      • http://twitter.com/ekimnamwen mike n

        mr anonymous hater, there’s no jealousy here. i know i have more talent in the tip of my pinky than joe swanberg has in his entire body. of course, this is saying much, but that’s not the point…i did in fact make a film exponentially better than any joe swanberg turd, a film that mocks every mumblecore movie ever made. it’s titled UNICORN NINJA SOLDIERS.

        you can find it on youtube. it has 150,000 views and counting. it was inspired by my hatred of mumblecore and i made it the same way mr swanberg makes his movies. it was conceived in 3 minutes, shot in 3 hours, and edited in 3 days. i put in as little effort as possible just to prove that even though the mumblecore style requires very little thought, it doesn’t have to be boring, smug, or unfunny.

  • Pingback: SEVEN OVERLOOKED INDEPENDENT FILMS OF 2011 | The … | Latest Films

  • Habu

    Cold Weather was a good movie???

  • http://www.zappestcontrolvirginia.com/ Jeremy Correl

    It seems Future had the potential to have been at least nominated at any film festival. There’s something about movies that run around an enigmatic and transcendental theme, and that same theme somehow makes for good cinematography. Movies are for audiences, and they do have the right to critic it.

     

  • Dan Delago

    I wanted to like Miranda July’s concept film, ‘The Future’ but I didn’t buy it.  The old guy she had an affair with in her film was completely unbelievable to me.  Now her husband in real  life, Mike Mills on the other hand, is a talented director.  His film, ‘Beginners’ was one of my favorites in 2011.

    Can you imagine what these two talk about over bagels and coffee in the morning?

  • Notmiken

    I’m gonna check out the movie and then I’ll get back to you

    • http://twitter.com/ekimnamwen mike n

      be prepared to have your mind blown away by it’s sheer brilliance. like a fine wine, it must be consumed slowly to the last drop to feel/understand its full effect.

      • Notmiken

        Haven’t watched the whole thing yet but it is a pretty good spoof of mumblecore and Lynch…better than I expected…

        • http://twitter.com/ekimnamwen mike n

          thanks. dan and geoff did a really great job at improvising. unlike all the actors in all mumblecore movies, they actually know how to improvise. dan is actually one of the best stand-up comedians working today.

          sadly, if i would’ve made the movie boring, dull, and unfunny like every joe swanberg movie, then certain indie film gatekeepers/tastemakers would probably be metaphorically sucking my balls right now.

  • Pingback: Pro[ACT]ive « Operation Blank

  • Saint I Ain’t

    Hang on a sec… Is this Miranda July??? Because only she would defend her crap-work with such fanatic vigor… There’s good art and bad art and while both are still arguably “art,” MJ’s tends to fall under the latter category… Why? Because as an official global audience member it is in my authority to say so. Now if you’ll excuse me I have to get bak to the set.

  • http://twitter.com/adamjeal Adam Jeal

    This has gone too far. If anything, It confirms my suspicion that most public discourse regarding film nowadays has degenerated into ‘A cult of celebrity’ where peoples opinions can’t get past the kind of buzz driven stupidity that is fueled by PR guys. Where is the discussion about the work?. Rather than childish stuff about who is or isn’t worthy to make independent films, can we please talk intelligently, and with passion about the work itself because ultimately, that’s all that really matters.

    • http://twitter.com/ekimnamwen mike n

      Adam, what exactly do you accomplish by talking passionately and “intelligently” about the work? How is that “all that matters”? And who made you king of what we can and cannot discuss?

      If you want to get serious about it, then it is quite childish to believe that any discussion on a blog post could provide any one with anything insightful, intelligent, or meaningful beyond a superficial level.

      With that said, it’s impossible to separate any of this particular work in this list from their creators b/c it is all self-indulgent and ultimately, trivial. Sure, some of these movies have some artistic merit, but in the end they are all meaningless and don’t provide any depth into humanity, nor do any of them reveal anything particularly insightful. In other words, these seven movies are all distractions from the things in life that really matter. I mean, in a nutshell that is what all narrative films are, eye candy.

      If you want to have a real intelligent conversation about films, a conversation that has substance, then that’s really only possible with documentaries, not fictional films. As much as narrative filmmakers want to believe that their movies are so meaningful, at the end of the day they are just exercises in self-masturbatory jubilation. I can’t watch a narrative film any more without “hearing” the director off in the background saying “hey, look at me, look at all the cool things I can do”.

      • http://twitter.com/adamjeal Adam Jeal

        Mike, none of this was directed at either you, or your comments about Swanberg at all (I was talking to the other guys). I’m just genuinely disappointed that most discussion re film tends to adopt a simplistic good/bad mentality without being able to see past the kind of PR bullshit & hype, both pro and anti whoever is being talked about. Whatever way you look at it, you could argue that both July & Swanberg have been the fortunate recipients of this PR machine in action.

        I disagree that fiction cannot be taken as seriously as documentaries. For me, creative expression, especially in the best music and poetry is a beautiful thing and at it’s best, cinema can expand on these things and go the extra mile. Without getting too hippy about it, cinema can all put us in a place that instantaneously fills us with awe and wonder and deepens life’s mysteries, making us ask more questions than before. That’s why it’ll never be just eye candy to me. I’ve slept, eaten breathed and farted film since I was five years old. That & music are my two great loves.

        No offense taken dude. If you want a PXL 2000 setup, I may be able to help you. Follow then DM me on twitter for the details.

VOD CALENDAR

Filmmaker's curated calendar of the latest video on demand titles.
Contagion The Guard Hell And Back Again
See the VOD Calendar →
Filmmaker's Best Of 2011

Entries (RSS) and Comments (RSS)

The Filmmaker Magazine Blog is powered by WordPress.org.